'Unisex' may work for fashion, but for PPE it's wrong

Gender-specific equipment is crucial for working at height.

Desiree Hlubi, Brand Manager, Sisi Safety Wear
Pinetown, KZN, SA (15 February 2023) - Notorious for workplace accidents and injuries on the job, construction is a risky business. Between working at heights, operating heavy machinery and hard physical labour, there is a lot of room for things to go wrong. While Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is designed to counter many of the hazards involved in construction, most safety wear is generally designed to fit and protect the male physique. As more women enter the construction, mining and engineering fields there is a growing need to reassess PPE by acknowledging the differences between the male and female anatomy and providing safety wear specifically designed to cater for these differences.
Safety first, for men and women
Employers have a duty to ensure a safe working environment. Part of this obligation includes a duty to ensure that PPE provided is fit for purpose, delivering a level of protection that matches the risk at hand. Accordingly, procurement managers and safety officers have a duty to provide PPE that meets the needs of each and every member of their workforce. Ordering men’s PPE in smaller sizes, or so-called ‘unisex’ PPE, is not enough to fulfil this duty. This can only be done by providing PPE that properly caters to the female form so that women enjoy the same benefits as men - the highest level of protection against health and safety risks, without the need to compromise on comfort.
Physiological differences impact PPE effectiveness
One of the most effective ways to make previously male-dominated industries more inclusive with immediate effect is to provide the correct PPE for women. Unisex PPE does not suitably fit female workers, but this is not a case of preference in comfort or fit, but rather a safety hazard. In fact, it is such a huge safety concern that it can be said that issuing women with PPE that does not fit correctly is on the same level as not providing any PPE at all.
Experiencing risk differently
Where there is a fall risk, such as working at heights, this danger is not the same for men and women. Unlike men, the risk of injury for women does not end when the fall is arrested. The polyester webbing typical to men’s fall arrest harnesses can cause secondary injury to the female wearer when placed below the bust area. This is because it can ride up and over the bust with force at the end of a fall. As such, it is necessary for women working at heights to wear PPE specifically designed for the female bust where the polyester chest strap webbing is replaced with an elasticated webbing that stretches in the event of a fall. This relieves the pressure on the bust area, reducing the risk of secondary injury. Of further importance for female safety is PPE fit. An adjustable chest strap makes provision for well-endowed women to position the strap in a way that provides comfort without unavoidably accentuating or placing strain on physical assets. In this way, fall arrest PPE specifically designed for the physical needs of women can play a major role in enhancing confidence and productivity in the workplace.
Another example of physiological inadequacy can be seen clearly in safety footwear. Given the differences between the male and female foot, wearing men’s safety footwear isn’t just ineffective for women, it's a safety hazard. The sizing does not translate, and a woman’s foot inside a man’s shoe will slide and experience side-to-side movement that can cause long term damage through calf and hip injuries.
Addressing gender equality in PPE
The limited availability of PPE for women is a critical workplace health and safety issue that must urgently be addressed by safety and procurement officers. It should not be treated as an additional administrative burden, but rather as a necessary step in ensuring that every member of the workforce is provided with suitable, fit-for-purpose protective gear. From a procurement perspective, there is simply no excuse to continue overlooking the PPE needs of women in the workplace and where it is not yet freely available, women in the workforce should know that they have the right to request the procurement of personal protective equipment that is designed to tick all the right boxes for their specific physique, ensuring safety without compromising on comfort and fit.
Footwear Industry Articles
- Obituary: Shan Pillay – Eddels, Jaguar Shoes, Divine Shoes (19/01/1936-28/05/2024) The quiet, ever-present photographerPietermaritzburg, KZN, SA – In the first place, my deepest condolences to Nellandran and Pritha and Uncle Shan’s five grandchildren. His passing on, as I’m sure you know, is not just a loss to your immediate and extended family and his close friends and colleagues, including in the media sector – but to all of us i ...more2025 FORECASTSBy common consent, 2024 has been a difficult year for almost all businesses, organisations, government departments and people in the SA leather value chain. The main exceptions would have been successful exporters, because the domestic market has been getting poorer year after year. The underlying reasons are mostly to do with the policie ...moreAI is putting an end to counterfeit sneakersOsmo’s AI-powered scent authentication machine in action, revolutionizing the fight against counterfeit sneakers by detecting unique chemical profiles with remarkable precision.As the sneaker resale market continues to boom, counterfeit goods remain a persistent concern for both luxury and mass-market brands. Counterfeiters have bec ...more
Leather Industry Articles
- Sam Setter's 'Pills': For readers who need some wry medicinal humourIt’s the middle-class market, not the rich, where the real money isAlthough I fully realise that luxury is a very important factor for the leather industry, I believe that we focus too much on this particular sector, and forget the day-to-day use of leather. There aren’t too many people who can afford a €100 000 bag, a &e ...moreGroenewald returns to OPSAOudtshoorn, W. Cape, SA – Newald Groenewald rejoined Ostrich Products SA (OPSA) in September as tannery manager.He started at the then Klein Karoo International in 1991 before joining OPSA as tannery manager in 2015. He joined Le Croc as tannery manager in 2021, and left there earlier this year. ...moreHide demand steady amid growing global supply, gelatine plants absorbing higher number of lower gradesThe picture I get of the leather industry globally is that it is losing share in all its markets for a variety of reasons. In South Africa, the situation is compounded by cash-strapped consumers choosing cheaper alternatives. Cape Produce Company is at the beginning of the leather process, and it supplies all leather markets in SA and internationally. I asked CEO Benjy Lapiner if the picture is as bleak as I’m told. No, he said, but… ...more
PPE Industry Articles
- Mitigate risks and enhance efficiency - the ISO accreditation advantageDurban, KZN, SA (11 September 2024) – ISO accreditation is a strategic investment that empowers businesses to enhance their competitiveness, mitigate risks, and seize new market opportunities. By adhering to globally recognised standards, organisations can build trust, streamline operations, and achieve sustainable growth. While the ...moreAI solution shows truck drivers where to parkBerlin, Germany (02 September 2024) – Parking spaces are in short supply at rest stops along Germany’s highways. Truck drivers are required by law to observe certain rest periods, so when they cannot find parking, they often simply park off to the side of an entrance or exit or on the shoulder, all of which are very ...moreThe Fire and Life Safety Blame Game!SFA: EMS Conference 10/24Leighton Bennett (BSc, MDP dip, Pr.CHSA, AIRMSA, GradSaiosh, .M.ACHASM, Former FIOSM)Safety First Association - Chairperson SHE and Risk Management ConsultantOverview• Fire and life safety aspects introduction • Owner / Lessor / Employer Fire and Life Safety Responsibilities • Meaning of life safety ...more