Developing a risk-based safety management system programme
At an OSHAfrica conference, speakers raised the topics of ‘Health & Safety Management Systems’ and ‘Safety Risk Management Systems’ which many people think of as vastly separated from each other.
The proposed Occupational Health & Safety Amendment Act (OHSAct) (not promulgated yet) is expected to require safety management systems and risk management to be performed at workplaces in the future.
As H&S practitioners, we have seen the publication of the 2018 ISO 45001 Occupational Health & Safety Management System that replaces the SANS OHSAS 18001 Health & Safety Management System, but how can we develop a risk-based H&S management system programme to manage Health & Safety (H&S) in the workplace?
The ISO 45001 Standard only gives us part of the process, as it only presents the framework for an H&S management system. To see the whole process, we must consider the SANS/ISO 31000 Risk Management – Principles & Guidelines Standard (of 2009 and now 2018), as it presents the relationship between the risk management principles, the risk management framework, and the risk management process. The 2009 and 2018 ISO 31000 Risk Management Standard documents present these relationships as follows:
Let’s consider the 2018 guidelines edition of the 31000 Principles, which provides a statement of 8 risk management principles, as follows:
1. The risk management framework and processes should be customised and proportionate for the organisation and its objectives.
2. The risk management system requires the appropriate and timely involvement of its stakeholders.
3. Risk management requires a structured and comprehensive approach to be applied.
4. Risk management is an integral part of all organisational activities.
5. Risk management anticipates, detects, acknowledges, and responds to changes.
6. Risk management explicitly considers any limitations of available information.
7. Human and cultural factors influence all aspects of risk management.
8. Risk management is continually improved through learning and experience.
For developing a health & safety management system, the risk management principles above can be adopted and made applicable as the principles of a health & safety management system by purely replacing the word ‘Risk’ in the risk management principles, cited above, by ‘Health & Safety’.
Then use the health & safety management framework illustrated in the ISO 450001 standard, with the addition of ‘worker participation’ contributing to the leadership.
The context refers to deciding whether just the internal influencing factors or the external influencing factors or both the internal and external factors influencing and/or impacting on the organisation or workplace are to be considered, within the decided scope of the management system and noting that these influencing factors can be positive or negative influences.
The criteria involves reflecting the organisation’s values, objectives, resources and the imposed regulatory factors in establishing and defining the risk criteria parameters to be used to evaluate the significant of the risks (hazards & exposures), by firstly identifying the risks, then analysing the magnitude of the identified risks, and finally evaluating the risk’s acceptability or not to the organisation’s sustainability.
The management system requires a risk assessment to be performed to identify, analyse and evaluate the risks using the decided risk criteria parameters. Many risk identification methods could be used, but identifying the risks by using the 7 critical resources which are ‘at risk’ in any business operation or for a project, namely by using the acronym PEPMELF, meaning the People, Equipment, Procedures/Processes/ Practices/Policies, Materials, Environment, Legal/Liability and Financial resources ‘at risk’ is a universal and user-friendly method to identify risks (hazards, exposures and threats). Note this PEPMELF method provides a higher level (baseline) risk assessment than a HIRA type of risk assessment.
The high risk-rated magnitude risks can be subjected to a Risk Treatment Response involving the 4T’s, namely risk Termination, Tolerance, Transfer and/or Treatment to reduce the risk rating to within the decided acceptable risk level of the organisation.
All risk assessments must be recorded for future monitoring and review and re-assessment if new or risk changes occur, while the whole OHS (Risk) management system and process must be communicated and consulted to promote the understanding of OHS/risk and the management system among all the organisation’s employees.
Returning to the management system framework: once the operational PLANS and management function are established, they are implemented as part of the ‘DO activities’. The functionality and performance of the management system processes need to be periodically CHECKED and evaluated, normally by audits (e.g. OHS audits) to ensure operational effectiveness and performance.
Where the CHECKS highlight non-conformances, such that management system improvements need to be made by performing ACTS to correct and/or to PLAN corrective measures or system changes to mitigate the risk to achieve an acceptable risk level, and these measures are again implemented through ‘DO activities’.
This article describes how one can easily develop a risk-based H&S management system programme by combining both the 31000 Risk Management & the 45001 H&S Management System standards.
References:
ISO 31000:2009/2018: Risk Management – Principles & guidelines standards
ISO 45001:2018: OHS Management Systems standard.
L Bennett, Risk Assessment – guide to understanding the basics, Safety First Association, published 2006, 2nd edition 2022. (www.safety1st.co.za)
7/2023 -10/2019
Leighton G Bennett is Sole Proprietor of and SHE and Risk Management Consultant with Benrisk Occupational & Construction Safety, Health, Environment & Risk Management Consultants, in Johannesburg (Established in 1999).
He holds a BSc Degree (Natal University) and a Management Development Programme (MDP) Diploma (Durban Westville University Business School), as well as some 28 qualifications and certificates covering: Safety, Fire, Occupational Hygiene, Risk Analysis, Risk Assessment, Enterprise-wide Risk Management, SHE & Risk Auditing, & Asset Maintenance (NOSA, ILCI, FPA, IRCA, DNV, Insurance Institute of USA, CE at Pretoria University, IRMSA/Alexander Forbes).
He is a member of a number of professional bodies and is director and chairperson of the Safety First Association.
He has written a number of articles for various publications.
And perhaps most intriguingly, he is a retired and undefeated SA Masters Ballroom Dancing Champion who, in 1996, represented SA at the World Senior Dance Sport Championships in Germany.
Contact details: Leighton Bennett, +27 (0)83 325 4182, benrisk@mweb.co.za, Benrisk Consulting, 62 Blanca Ave, Berario, Johannesburg, 2195, Gauteng, SA.
Footwear Industry Articles
- Bata SA: Renewed effort to grow brands with chainsBubblegummers to be ‘a priority product’Durban, KZN, SA – Broadening Bata South Africa’s brand base is a priority – perhaps the priority – for country manager Lorraine Dyer, who joined in August with a background managing apparel brands including Converse and Calvin Klein.That has been the goal under su ...moreWhat if South Africa loses AGOA? A hypothetical scenario for the footwear export industryThe interconnected nature of trade, politics, and diplomacy reminds us that no industry operates in isolation. The possibility of South Africa losing its AGOA (African Growth and Opportunity Act) benefits is purely hypothetical, but exploring such scenarios helps us plan for resilience and adaptability. This article is a thought exercise ...moreSAFLIA: Hopefully the slide will be reversedDurban, KZN, SA – My forecast for 2024 is that production will be 12.5% down on last year. Meaning 41,690,000 pairs.The last time we saw such low volumes was in 2007.My forecast for next year is that production will be stabilised at the same level as this year – let’s say 42,000,000 pairs. However, with some serious inte ...more
Leather Industry Articles
- Update on FMD in SA: 4 provinces declared free from foot and mouth disease outbreaksPretoria, Gauteng, SA (25 October 2024) – The Department of Agriculture has announced that the Foot and Mouth Disease (FMD) outbreak, which occurred during 2021-2022, has been successfully resolved in the North West, Free State, Gauteng, and Mpumalanga Provinces. These provinces, which were initially impacted by the outbreak, have n ...moreHide demand steady amid growing global supply, gelatine plants absorbing higher number of lower gradesThe picture I get of the leather industry globally is that it is losing share in all its markets for a variety of reasons. In South Africa, the situation is compounded by cash-strapped consumers choosing cheaper alternatives. Cape Produce Company is at the beginning of the leather process, and it supplies all leather markets in SA and internationally. I asked CEO Benjy Lapiner if the picture is as bleak as I’m told. No, he said, but… ...moreA cost-effective method of reducing loose grain damage during the bating processIntroductionEnzymatic bating is an important part of the leather making process. Bating enzymes help remove unwanted skin components from the hide structure, as well as any scud present on the grain layer. Good bating leads to clean, soft leather. Under bating results in poor removal of unwanted skin components, and a firmer crust leather ...more
PPE Industry Articles
- MBA North members place in top 4 of every category in MBSA National Safety Competition – againMaster Builders Association North (MBA North) members have continued their multi-year winning streak by being placed in the top four of every category in the 2024 Master Builders South Africa (MBSA) National Safety Competition (NSC) – the flagship event for health and safety in the building industry.Gerhard Roets, Health and Safety ...moreOffshore wind energy: Mobile test platform for offshore wind turbinesBremerhaven, Germany (02 September 2024) – Public power grids are highly complex systems. Wind turbine manufacturers have to comply with technical guidelines when connecting new turbines to avoid putting grid stability at risk. In the Mobil-Grid-CoP project, researchers at the Fraunhofer Institute for Wind Energy Systems IWES have d ...moreAutomatic image recognition to identify types of wood: Harnessing AI to fight global deforestationKaiserslautern, Germany (02 September 2024) – The new European Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) is intended to prevent goods marketed in the EU from contributing to the spread of deforestation. When a wood product is brought into the EU market, for example, there must be documentation of which types of wood were used to produce it, a ...more